Talk:Saturna Island

From Wikivoyage
Jump to navigation Jump to search

"Park" or "Small city" template?[edit]

This article is presently formatted according to the Wikivoyage:Park article template. I suppose this is reasonable if you think that the island is 44% park, so is a park with civilian areas around it. I know someone who lives there, so from my perspective it's a small town with a park. In that case, the Wikivoyage:Small city article template would be more appropriate. How do they differ? The Small city template has no "Fees/Permits" or "Stay safe" sections, which are pretty minimal here. The Park template has no "Connect" section. I believe that most of "See", "Do", "Eat", "Drink" will be listings outside the park, not in. The differences are small enough that we can improve the "See", "Do", "Eat", "Drink" sections first, and implement a decision about which template later. P.S. I certainly think that the island meets the Wikivoyage:What is an article? criteria; I'm not suggesting we merge this article into something else. JimDeLaHunt (talk) 00:28, 30 June 2016 (UTC)[reply]