| Article |
Status |
To do |
|---|
| Gandhinagar |
Outline |
Well listified now, but needs more content and a map. The pagebanner is well-composed by not beautiful, but perhaps it's a fair representation of the city. |
| Ahmedabad |
Usable |
As it stands, this is a very poorly districted huge city article, with loads of listings that should be moved to district articles. The "Tourist Map of Ahmedabad" is not Wikivoyage-style and sucks. There were some double-parentheses in "Get in," but I think I fixed them all. Overall, there's a lot of content, and though many improvements have been made to this article, the content still is not very well structured, considering that a lot of it needs to be moved to district articles. |
| Bhavnagar |
Usable |
Many improvements have been made to this article. It is now substantially listified, although not in "Drink", and "Eat" is not completely listified. Several attractive photos were added. Still needs a pagebanner, map and additional information, and also requires copy editing. |
| Jamnagar |
Usable |
This city seems interesting, but the information in the article is still poorly structured in places. Improvements have been made, so that it is now a weak Usable article, rather than an Outline, but it needs some investment in time for copy editing, including editing out Unnecessarily Capitalized Words, and to restructure the "Eat" section. |
| Junagadh |
Usable |
This article has also been improved quite a bit and is now Usable. It's mostly listified, but "Do" is still a mess of names in lieu of informative listings. Also still needs pagebanner/map, and several sections require more information (descriptions). |
| Rajkot |
Usable |
Great work has been done on this article, which is now Usable and mostly listified. The "Eat" section is looking like the one that most obviously still needs more work. Also still needs a map and pagebanner. |
| Surat |
Outline |
Interesting article, but a little rough. Needs more information in places, including the locations of "See" listings, and definitely more listification. There are also various formatting problems. This article really is not yet Usable, as there is no contact info for any restaurant and location info for "See" listings is not too pinpoint. Let's make it at least unquestionably Usable. If it were a Guide, it would definitely be Off the Beaten Path for foreign tourists. |
| Vadodara |
Usable |
Another fairly interesting-sounding city, but probably more interesting than it currently sounds. If it's really the "Oxford of Gujarat," as claimed in its 1-liner listing in the Gujarat article, why aren't its universities listed in "See"? (MSU was listed, just not prominently, and that has been remedied somewhat, but there should probably be an entire subsection for its listing, with various important and beautiful buildings described, as in the Oxford and Cambridge (England) articles.) Needs listification (update:mostly listified) and location info in listings and images beyond the pagebanner a city map. Some copy editing has taken place, but more remains to be done. |
