User:Ikan Kekek/Bad region articles
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Bad articles
[edit]- Abov - Only 2 blue links, let alone information about individual sights.
- Achaea - Almost no content. Should it be merged and redirected to Patras?
- Acre (Brazil) - Very little content: every section after "Get in" is empty. Should that, Rondônia and Roraima, also almost contentless articles, be combined with Amazonas (Brazil), so that that article is about four states?
- Adygea - nothing in "See," one thing in "Do". Only two blue links. I will propose a merge and redirect to Krasnodar Krai, which should be renamed Krasnodar Krai and Adygea. However, that article has blank "See" and "Do" sections. Redirected to the new article, but still needs more work.
- Agreste (Pernambuco) – no content outside Cities/OD
- Agrigento (province) - virtually no content.
- Ahal Province and all other region articles in Turkmenistan totally suck. I'm proposing merging and redirecting them all to the country article. – partially improved. I've filled out the See section of this specific article, "Do", "Eat" and "Drink" are still empty, though I don't consider the latter two crucial for a region article. --SHB2000 (talk | contribs | meta) 12:49, 18 May 2023 (UTC)
- Ajmer Division and all other region articles of Rajasthan have virtually no content. Rajasthan is very large in area, so I'm concerned about the ramifications of merging and redirecting all region articles, but we will have to consider the possibility. I (Ikan Kekek) don't want to write up another deregionalization proposal right now and add it to requests for comment, so I'll come back to this.
- Amapá - Almost no content. Should it and the slightly less sparse Tocantins article be merged with Pará (Brazil) to form a 3-state article that will still need a bit more fleshing out?
- Ancona (province) – minimal content outside "Cities" and "Other destinations" sections
- Antequera Region – 1 blue link, empty past "Get in"
- Belluno (province) – 3 blue links in "Cities", minimal content otherwise
- Bhopal-Narmadapuram Division – 6 blue links, minimal get in info; all other sections are empty
- Bikaner Division – 3 blue links, minimal content otherwise
- Cagliari (province) – contains a single link and no content elsewhere. Redirect to Cagliari?
- Capiz – minimal content outside "Cities" and "Other destinations" sections
- Central Bosnia – 3 blue links, no content elsewhere
- Central East (Rio Grande do Sul) – has 3 blue links, an awful amount of red links and that's about it
- Central Isaan – empty See/Do sections
- Central Leningrad Oblast – 1 blue link, no content elsewhere
- Central South (Bahia) – minimal content outside "Cities" and "Other destinations" sections
- Central Sudan – minimal content outside "Cities" and "Other destinations" sections
- Chaco (Argentina) – empty after "Get around"
- Cumberland County (Maine) – 3 blue links, contains mapshape; all other sections are empty
- Cuvette – minimal content. Merger proposed at Talk:Republic of the Congo
- Eastern Cambodia minimal content outside the "Cities" and "Other destinations" sections
- Eastern Plantations – 2 blue links, minimal get in info, all other sections are empty
- Eastern Uganda – no content outside "Cities" and "Other destinations"
- Essex County (New Jersey) – no content outside "Cities" section
- Foggia (province) – no content outside "Cities" and "Other destinations"
- Great Lakes (South Dakota) – 2 blue links, minimal get in info; all other sections are empty -- proposal made to turn this into a rural area and merge in four towns.
- Greater Hobart – has see listings which should be moved to the relevant city article
- Grundy County (Illinois) – 1 blue link, empty elsewhere
- Inner Eastern Thailand – 5 blue links with all other sections empty
- Kalahari – 3 blue links with all other sections empty
- Lara (Venezuela) – only contains one blue link -- merger proposed at Talk:Minas Gerais
- Loyalty Islands – one blue link, limited content in other sections. Could Ouvéa possibly be merged with the current region article to form a rural area article?
- Massa-Carrara (province) – only contains 3 blue links and a few images
- All of Maranhão's subregions are abysmal, many of which have minimal to no content outside the "Cities" or "Other destinations" sections: Central Maranhão, Eastern Maranhão, Northern Maranhão, Western Maranhão and Southern Maranhão
- North (Minas Gerais) and Northwest (Minas Gerais) – both are abysmal. The latter has 0 blue links and no content outside lede -- reorganization proposed at Talk:Northwest (Venezuela)
- North (Paraná) – only contains 1 blue link
- Northeastern Bosnia – only contains 3 blue links
- Northeastern Tamil Nadu – 2 blue links, otherwise abysmal in content
- Northern Sierra (Peru) – no content outside "Regions" and "Cities" section
- Northwest (Espírito Santo) – 2 blue links, otherwise abysmal in content
- Pisa (province) – 5 blue links, no content outside "Cities" section
- Pistoia (province) – 3 blue links, no content outside "Cities" section
- Sagadahoc County – 4 blue links, little to no content outside "Cities" and "Other destinations" sections
- Sertão (Pernambuco) – 2 blue links, no content outside "Cities" section
- Sikasso (region) – 1 blue link, no content outside "Cities" section
- South Sichuan – 2 blue links, minimal get in info; all other sections are empty
- Southern Maranhão – 1 blue link, 6 red links, no content outside "Cities" section
- Many of Tajikistan's regions suck – I've (SHB2000) made a proposal to revise the region structure on Talk:Tajikistan
- Val di Elsa
- Verona (province)
- Western Coal Fields – 3 blue links, no content outside "Cities" section
- Western Highlands (Liaoning)
- Yaracuy – 0 blue links, minimal content in Understand-- merger proposed at Talk:Northwest (Venezuela)
- Yazd (province) – 1 blue link, minimal understand and get in info
- Yemeni Coastal Plains
- Yemeni Highlands – minimal content overall
Articles that need more links
[edit]- Abia State has substantial information in "See" and "Do" but needs more of the attractions to be linked to local articles.
- Abruzzo - "See" and "Do" need links.
- Acadiana - Pretty good region article, but "Do" needs links to city articles.
- Aceh - See and Do need more links. See has what's arguably an overly long list, but what's most important is to say what cities each attraction is in, with relevant links.
Other issues
[edit]- Acadia is an extra-region with individual listings that have markers instead of links to city articles.
- The boundaries between Andean Northwest (Argentina) and Chaco (Argentina) is not well-defined, both on the map and in our region structure – see Talk:Argentina
- East Estonia is a region with plenty of travel content, but it contains many listings for places that do not have articles.
Improved articles
[edit]- 24 Parganas - Empty "See and Do" section.
- Aba (prefecture) - Nothing in "See."
- Abitibi-Témiscamingue - "See" and "Do" need links. -- Done. Ground Zero (talk) 22:55, 14 May 2023 (UTC)
- Abu Dhabi (emirate) - Nothing in "See."
- Acadian Coast - See" and "Do" need links. Improved. --SHB2000 (talk | contribs | meta) 11:36, 26 May 2023 (UTC)
- Adams County (Pennsylvania) – region article with only one blue link; "See" section contains listings -- merged into higher-level region. Ground Zero (talk) 19:56, 31 May 2023 (UTC)
- Adelaide Region - nothing specific in "See" or "Do". Improved --SHB2000 (talk | contribs | meta) 03:28, 20 May 2023 (UTC)
- Altai (Kazakhstan) – minimal content outside "Cities" and "Other destinations" sections; potential Wikivoyage:Image policy violations, too. Improved. Ground Zero (talk) 20:18, 3 June 2023 (UTC)
- Antananarivo Province – 2 blue links, minimal information in see, abysmal elsewhere -- Improved. Ground Zero (talk) 19:14, 26 May 2023 (UTC)
- Barletta-Andria-Trani – empty outside "Cities" section
- Blaauwberg Coast – no content outside "Cities" section
- Broome County – minimal content
- Central Greece - subregion articles merged.
- Cape Karoo – 2 blue links, minimal content outside "Cities" and "Other destinations" sections — merged into Western Cape Karoo
- Central Senegal – only contains 7 blue links in "Cities" section
- Central Zambia – minimal content outside "Cities", "Other destinations" and "Talk" sections. Improved Ground Zero (talk) 21:24, 21 May 2023 (UTC)
- Cornwall County – 3 blue links, a few points about the county's parishes, no content elsewhere. Ground Zero (talk) 03:26, 16 May 2023 (UTC)
- Eastern Kenya – 4 blue links, 1 red-linked OD; all other sections are empty Improved Ground Zero (talk) 11:42, 16 May 2023 (UTC)
- Entre Rios – content is abysmal beyond "Other destinations" Improved. --SHB2000 (talk | contribs | meta) 12:52, 30 May 2023 (UTC)
- Eritrea has two region articles that absolutely suck – merged with Eritrea --SHB2000 (talk | contribs | meta) 03:58, 3 June 2023 (UTC)
- Evrytania – merged
- Gemer – many empty sections. Improved. Ground Zero (talk) 11:24, 26 May 2023 (UTC)
- Isfahan (province) – 7 blue links with most other sections empty
- North Aegean Islands – no content outside "Regions" section. -- Improved. Ground Zero (talk) 01:40, 26 May 2023 (UTC)
- North Central Wisconsin – 9 blue links; empty otherwise
- Northern Senegal – 2 blue links, limited content in the "See" section, no content in other sections
- North Western Province (Sri Lanka) – minimal information in "Understand", 4 blue links, and a bunch of spurious empty section headers in "Do"
- Nuoro (province) – little to no content outside "Cities" and "Other destinations" sections
- Pando – 0 blue links, no content outside "Understand" and "Cities" section -- Improved, as much as is feasible from Wiki sources. Ground Zero (talk) 01:21, 19 May 2023 (UTC)
- Phocis – 3 blue links, no content outside "Cities" section – merged
- San Juan (province, Argentina) – little to no content outside "Cities" and "Other destinations" sections Improved –SHB2000 (talk | contribs | meta) 13:16, 19 May 2023 (UTC)
- Tambacounda Region – 4 blue links, a little bit of content in "See", but otherwise empty - Improved Ground Zero (talk) 12:31, 18 May 2023 (UTC)
- Tarn-et-Garonne – 2 blue links, no content outside "Cities" section - Improved Ground Zero (talk) 21:30, 19 May 2023 (UTC)
- Toliara Province – little to no content outside "Cities" and "Other destinations" sections- Improved Ground Zero (talk) 12:26, 19 May 2023 (UTC)
- Val di Chiana - Improved Ground Zero (talk) 17:20, 16 May 2023 (UTC)
- Volta Delta – 3 blue links, no content outside of the "Cities" and "Other destinations" sections